
Discipline....The meaning of this word is to teach, right? There is one part of Positive Discipline that gets me, they say not to take things away. What? How do you not do that?
Apparently, there is positive discipline and there is negative discipline. Personally, I feel that the only positive discipline that works with my children is bribery. Here is a good and common scenario at our house......
The family is eating dinner and Amber continues to jump up from the table to look at the television in the other room. I tell her to sit down and eat with the family, say 10 times, but she continues to bounce up from her seat like there is a spring in her rear end. Do I say....a) If you stay seated you can have dessert; b) If you get up again and look at the TV I am going to take away dessert; or c) Say nothing and just let her continue to be rude to the rest of the family?
Honestly, I know that if I tell her that if she sits down she can have dessert she will sit, but she will pop up again. If I tell her the dessert will be gone, she will sit like her butt has become glued to the seat. But, taking away the dessert is not considered a positive action in the positive discipline scenario.
I guess I feel like, as parents, we are supposed to be preparing our children for the world. We have to get them to a place where they can leave our homes and know how to live on their own. We need to make sure that they are honest, responsible, and independent. We also need to make sure they are prepared for other people in the world. People that don't love them. People who could care less if they have food on their tables to eat at night.
I know from experience that positive discipline is not out their in the working world. I have never had a boss tell me that if I continue to be late for work I will be able to keep my job. I know that if I had been late for work too many times they would have fired me. Don't children need to know that bad things happen when they don't do things the right way?
I truly feel that you should praise your children when they do things in a positive way, cleaning up, having good grades, being polite, brushing their teeth, helping someone, being generous, sharing their toys, etc. I also think they should be scolded, or have consequences for their actions so that they know how to act in life.
It really rubs me the wrong way when I see someone out in a restaurant letting their children run wild and not teaching them how to act in public. I know that when we leave our children with other people, they behave. They know that the Wrath of Mama will terrorize them the next day if they don't act right. I expect things from them that I know they are fully capable of doing. I know they can use good manners and treat others with respect. I know that they are able to clean up behind themselves. They know how to follow directions. Sometimes they may try to get away with something out of the norm, but they are usually pretty quick to jump back in line. I also don't want my children to be looked at like they are heathens when we are out in the public.
We went out to dinner one night, or I should say tried to go out to dinner one night. We had a new restaurant that we wanted to try, it was the weekend before Mother's Day and two of the kids weren't going to be with us on the actual Mother's Day so we were going out a week early.
Anyway, we get to the restaurant and there is a wait, but it was early and we weren't hungry yet so we decided to wait. It was going a 30-minute wait. It was sort of windy outside so we decided to sit in the van until the little buzzer thing went off. Well, the entire time we were in the van the kids would not sit still (except for Wesley, he was still in his car seat and unable to walk anyway). They were changing seats, rocking the van, it looked like we had a party going on from the outside for sure. The two problems with this is that one of them kept landing on Wesley while changing seats and I get car sick, the van was rocking and I was getting ill.
Finally, Tony decided we should get out of the van because they were getting loud and, well the whole ill feeling thing was going on. We walk up to the outside of the restaurant and one child decided to climb up the wall, another is opening the door for the other patrons (very nice idea, but she was on the wrong side of the door) and the other child was trying to climb up the first child climbing the wall. I moved Amber from the door so that the people could get in the restaurant, grabbed Justin off of Kelsey's back and told Kelsey to stop acting like a monkey. We had been up there for 1 minute.
Next, Amber moved to the curb, she was going to balance on it, hopefully. Justin found some rocks to throw and Kelsey was trying to do something I have forgotten by now. We told them, more than ten times to be still. To just wait a few more minutes and we were going to be seated. They couldn't contain themselves. We even explained that if it were just one child jumping, skipping, balancing, climbing and throwing rocks it wouldn't seem quite as busy as four children doing them simultaneously. I told them we would leave it I had to tell them one more time. We found an empty bench to sit on. There was plenty of room for all of us to sit, but the girls decided to spread their legs out and then Justin decided to sit on one of their knees, they screamed and then I said, "Get in the van...now." No yelling, no screaming, from me.
Kelsey calmly walked to the van hanging her head. Amber began her "No Mommy. Why Mommy, please Mommy, I waaaanttt to eeeeeaaaaaaatttttt, please Mommy, don't Mommy, I am hunnnnnnngrrry." Justin stood in the middle of the sidewalk and screamed as loud as he could scream. I carried my quiet son, Wesley, to the van, while grabbing my screaming son from the sidewalk by the elbow, gave him a slight pop on the rear for screaming when we got to the van and we left. They had oatmeal for dinner and Tony and I had sandwiches.
My reaction was probably all wrong according to the discipline counsel of yadayadayada. But, I know something for sure, the next time we went to dinner those were the quietest, most well behaved, cute little kids I have ever seen. They were pleased to be eating out of the house, since we don't get to many times. They understand that eating out as a family is a treat and they should act accordingly. We want to have fun at dinner, have good conversation and laugh. That is fun to us.
I know it probably seems that I am the one doing most of the talking when the kids are acting up. I believe that has to do with the way my husband and I were raised. I have turned into my parents and now, 15 years after the fact, I am grateful for the energy they mustered up to teach me. My children question my rules at times and I have to tell them the same thing my mom told me, some parents take the easy way. It is easy to let your kids play outside and tell them to be home at a certain time. It takes more energy to actually make sure they are doing what they are supposed to be doing. I know that I make a lot of things harder on myself than some parents would, but I want to make sure my kids are safe, unharmed, never kidnapped, without broken limbs and I want to make sure I can hear them cry when they happen to fall down and scrape their knees.